Psychology of Spaces
Psychology is not a subject that comes up in green building much, but its
generally what is most important to occupants. When you're sitting in a
building you don't generally think about how much energy or materials it
consumes over its lifetime--you think about how it looks and feels.
Americans tend to be adverse to anything having to do with psychology, but in
this context psychology is just mostly about likes and dislikes.
Trying find common truth about humans is notoriously difficult, yet there
are things we tend to share, even if they're not quite universal. The
following section is summary of the psychology behind the design patterns:
they serve both to explain the "why" behind the patterns, but also as a
summary of them.
There are really two categories of psychological impact a building has:
its style, and for lack of a better word, its comfort. To use an
analogy from clothing, style is about how you feel when you dress up (or
not) and go out, while comfort is more like pajamas. Its the later
topic that is covered here; a discussion on style is
here.
The Concepts1
- People are drawn to the sun. Its why people flock to warm climates in
winter. Except in the hottest weather, people then gravitate to the shade.
Even when they don't want to be in the sun they want to be near it or at least
have access to it (again, except when it so hot you feel like you need to hide).
- People are drawn to light, but not too much light. Dark corners
and hallways aren't generally appealing, but neither are rooms that are so
bright people have to squint. Light tends to be associated with activity
and dark with quiet or sleep because our bodies are designed that way.
People, when entering a new space will naturally move to the light and
avoid the dark, hence a dark space can act as a psychological barrier.
- People prefer natural light to electric light, but at night they by
far prefer the warm
color associated with incandescent light over any bulb that produces "daylight"
color. How much of this is innate, and how much is cultural is
unclear. What is clear is that warm light is the color of fire,
and people like to look a fire. Additionally the light from bulbs
radiates from a point, while sunlight washes the room more uniformly,
but even if bulb reproduced sunlight exactly, its not clear that it
would be appealing: its still dark out, and in our minds we know that.3
- People like to look at nature. Most people find nature peaceful, and
appear to be just as happy looking at a manicured backyard as they do into the
woods. The key is green and serene.
- People will gravitate to any location where they can observe others moving
about the area, but are not themselves in a place they feel on stage. The
edge of a field is more comfortable than the middle, but not just any edge, but
one where the field is generally visible. Most people will prefer a
location where their back does not feel vulnerable exposed. By placing a
sizeable object in the middle of an area (a large room, an outdoor space etc)
the middle can become more like an edge, and people will then gravitate toward
it.
- Ceiling height affects the sense of psychological space as well as the sense
of feeling protected; room size also matters. People sense ceiling height in
terms of their own height. A low ceiling, particularly one that is low enough a
person can touch it evokes a sense of protection, although lower than that can
be claustrophobic. A very tall ceiling increases the feeling of
psychological distance: this is why a person sitting three feet away in a tall
ceiling train station feels further than one sitting 3 feet away in an airport2.
- People do not like to linger in a place where others will pass by in very
close proximity, but rather prefer to hang back at least a few feet.
- People need quiet time, but don't like feeling isolated. While this
sounds contradictory, it really isn't. Its why consultants, freelance
writers etc spend much of their day in coffee shops. When people choose to
be alone, they don't necessary want to feel alone. Extroverts, by nature
need far less quiet time than introverts.
- Stairs, doorways, and hallways act as psychological barriers,
especially when they are darker than the surrounding space. Occupied rooms can
also be barriers, as in the odd awkward case where you have to walk thru one
bedroom to get to another.
- People do not want to be seen coming in and out of bathrooms, most
particularly guests. Bathroom activities are intensely private for most
people, and so the only people they are comfortable making aware of them are
close family members.
- People gravitate toward kitchens, particularly if there is activity in the
kitchen. This is especially relevant for guests: if you want them out of
the kitchen you need to design for that.
- People like it to be obvious what is expected of them, in terms of
what spaces they can go in to.
Notes
1: Most of these ideas can be found in Alexander, et al, "A Pattern
Language", with a few adopted from other sources. The presentation here is
much simplified and organized somewhat differently. Those interested
should read the original--its a few hundred pages.
2: even the airport ceiling is likely ten feet high or more, as are virtually
all commercial buildings, which is high enough. The effect appears
non-linear: the change from 8 feet to 12 feet seems as significant as the change
from 12 to 20.
3: There is a lot of speculation in these statements, but I suspect the
sales stats on light bulbs for residential applications is that warm out
sells cool many times although was unable to find sales stats. Note
that in commercial settings, particularly retail, cooler colors are much
more common.